nullstream weblog - The case against Apple

« traceroute + ping = mtr | SSD (yay or nay)? »

The case against Apple


August 9, 2009 03:16 PM PST

The Case Against Apple-in Five Parts

The article is pretty good, but I really got a kick out of the comments. I found this one part way down:

If Microsoft managed the Windows PC world the way Apple manages the iPhone/iPod touch world, Apple’s revenue would be less than half of what it is today. Imagine:

Steve: Hi, we’ve just submitted the Windows version of our iTunes app to the Windows app store.

Bill: Interesting. It looks like it duplicates existing functionality of the Windows OS, which includes Windows Media Player. Rejected.

Steve: What? There are similarities, yes, but iTunes provides a clean, easy to use interface for managing, purchasing, and playing music. Further, it allows Windows users to connect their iPods to their PCs and sync their music library seamlessly.

Bill: Sorry, our policy still stands. Besides, third party applications aren’t allowed direct access to music stored on a user’s PC.

Steve: But then how will we revolutionize the portable media player market and the mobile phone market, boosting our Mac market share and making billions of dollars in the process?

Bill: You won’t.

I wonder what revolutionary apps/gear/services we’ll miss out on because Apple finds them inconvenient.


There are also some good comparisons betweens Microsoft's anti-trust case for 'including' I.E. and Apple's down right 'rejection' of competing browsers like Opera mobile.

I'm enjoying the negative press Apple is getting, because hey I'm sick that way. But in the end I just want them to open things up a bit, and stop being, you know, evil.

Before you spam me, let me state that I do realize that the iPhone is not an open platform and they have the right to do what ever they want with 'their' product. I think the point being made in the market however is that consumers really want it to be open. Now I'm no business major, but I think that sometimes, just sometimes, it is a good idea to give customers what they want.

Comments (3)
Paul, August 9, 2009 06:01 PM:

I'm hoping that the FCC investigation and the general bad press Apple is getting willl make them open up. I doubt it though, this is a part of their corporate culture.

The real solution is to vote with your dollars and buy other products. I've been using the latest Android software, and it's really nice. It doesn't have quite the UI polish that the iPhone has, but it's getting close. My next phone will likely be an Android phone + Google Voice. I'm just waiting for a slimmer Android (no physical keyboard) to be released...

Paul, August 22, 2009 12:37 AM:

Interesting article (I have no inside information either way).

John, August 22, 2009 03:01 AM:

Yeah, Apple is pretty full of crap on this one. Not too many people are going to buy that story. I'm guessing the app will be released in a couple of weeks. -Oops 'our bad'.

All links will be marked with the nofollow tag, making them useless for search rankings. Any posts containing spam URLs will then be deleted.